If you aren’t
watching the new show on NBC called Chicago Fire you should be. The show has a
great pedigree it comes from Dick Wolf of Law and order fame and a friend Derek
Hass. I don’t give it a strong recommend because I know some of the people
involved, but rather because it is serving an educational roll in my opinion.
After the
first episode my sister called me. She was nearly in tears after having watched
the show. She told me that the show had given her so much insight into my 31
year career, that she was truly affected by what she had seen.
I had
watched the first episode as well and had found it to be very well written and
it portrayed firefighters and the job very accurately. I emailed Derek and
complimented on a job well done. He thanked me and also told me that it seemed I
was in a very small minority of firefighters that felt that way.
He had
found that a huge number of firefighters were objecting to the way the show was
being done. It wasn’t true to the job, it was overly dramatic. Here are some
quotes from the comments section following the first episode.
“BAD,
SUCKS, AND WASTE OF TIME!”
“The
advisers might have their hands tied because some over dramatic producer wants
it to be more of a night time soap than a true rescue show and if that's the
case, they should walk off the job now.”
“I know that the show is going after young viewers but on any
professional fire dept. they make us shave at every shift. So why do the main
characters both Lieutenants of their respective companies not have to be clean
shaven? Come on!!
Also, It would be extremely rare to see a 30-something Captain/Lieutenant of a big city fire department's Rescue company? Rescue companies are the best of the best and the only ones recruited onto the rescue companies are those that have spent years on busy truck and engine companies within the city. Thus making a 30-something leader of Chicago's Rescue 3 hard to believe.
Another miss on the technical advisers that this show is using is, With all of the sexual harassment policies that we as fire fighters have to go through with female & male firefighters working together, there is no way you would have a female in the locker room and shower area along with male firefighters walking around in just their towels.. Wrong Wrong!!”
Also, It would be extremely rare to see a 30-something Captain/Lieutenant of a big city fire department's Rescue company? Rescue companies are the best of the best and the only ones recruited onto the rescue companies are those that have spent years on busy truck and engine companies within the city. Thus making a 30-something leader of Chicago's Rescue 3 hard to believe.
Another miss on the technical advisers that this show is using is, With all of the sexual harassment policies that we as fire fighters have to go through with female & male firefighters working together, there is no way you would have a female in the locker room and shower area along with male firefighters walking around in just their towels.. Wrong Wrong!!”
“I'm with you Cap'n. Been in the service for 21
years and found little reality in this whatsoever. I realize Hollywood has to
get their dirty little fingers in the drama of it all, but the demographic that
would watch this show (firefighters/EMT's) should be very disappointed.”
I could go
on for another dozen pages, but I won’t. Maybe I have a different perspective
because of my background in writing screenplays and for television. I
understand the compromises that have to be made to pull off a show like Chicago
Fire. The idea is to tell a compelling story about a very difficult profession.
Because we
firefighters live it on a daily basis we watch a show like this and nitpick it to
pieces. I get that it isn’t 100% accurate of what we do and how we do it. But
do you think police officers watch cop shows and agree with them? Do you think
doctors watch doc shows and say oh yeah that’s how we do it or lawyers and so
on and so on?
Of course
it can’t be totally accurate, do you think filming in a real fire would render
any useable images? Of course not you can’t see a stinking thing in there as we
well know. But give this show a break over all they are doing a good job of
portraying our profession.
If you knew
how many times I heard a Chief yell “Casey in my office now.” You would be
amazed. I delivered nine babies in my career I was a drunk and abused pain
killers due to a shoulder injury while on duty. I carried dead people out of
buildings and got caught in flashovers and went out the window not in it. I
fell through floors and had my brothers pull me out.
I short I
have experienced most of what is being portrayed on Chicago Fire first hand. Now
it took over 30 years to rack up those stats they didn’t all happen in the
first week I was on the job.
So my
brothers and sisters in the profession relax a little. Over all this show is
showing us pretty much as we are, with warts and problems. If you have been on
the job for more than ten years you can’t honestly tell me you haven’t seen
everything on this show in one form or another.
Remember the
compromises Chicago Fire makes is for the sake of storytelling, they respect us
and honor us as best they can. I have seen interviews with the cast and the way
they admire real firefighters is touching, they want to show as we are. But you
don’t hire people that look like these people and not show them off.
So they don’t
shave and walk around with their shirts off, oh no one of the women is a
lesbian (Trust me I worked with a lot of lesbians and they were good
firefighters) how cliché, the Chief runs on every call never happens.
But they
way they show life in the house is pretty accurate in my opinion. The show will
get better I believe and it is. It does no harm they don’t lie about us at
least not in my opinion.
So here’s
to Chicago Fire, the cast the crew, the producers and the fans I like this show
and I must admit it makes me miss a job I loved so much, so give them a chance,
not every firefighting show can be Rescue Me.
6 comments:
You make me want to give it a try! When does it run in Colorado Springs? I'm a big fan of NCIS, which I'm sure wouldn't please everybody in the FBI! And so you've been a screenwriter and TV writer! Didn't realize that! Very interesting!
Hey Lorinda, you should give it a try it is on Wednesdays at 9:00 pm on NBC. http://www.nbc.com/chicago-fire/
You're always interesting. Hope you're having some luck with the job search.
Actually I got a job starting on January 2nd, thanks for asking.
I watch it every week, and I see some strong similarities between what you have written, and what I am seeing. Perhaps I blur the lines myself when it comes to being able to see the storytelling aspect as just that, but the combination of what Chicago Fire shares, and what you have shared are close enough to be kindred stories. Off to watch it now. ;-) Gotta love DVR's!
Thanks Rain, i wish firefighters would ease up on the show.
Post a Comment